Everton appear close to securing a long-term loan move for rising talent Antonio Cordero, but the nature of the deal is already raising eyebrows — including from Premier League legend and pundit Alan Shearer. The 20-year-old forward is set to join the Toffees next week on a season-long loan, yet the deal comes with a significant caveat: no option to buy.
And that, in Shearer’s eyes, may be a serious setback for a club still battling to rebuild.
The former Newcastle and England striker, known for his no-nonsense punditry, didn’t hold back when reacting to the news. Speaking on a Premier League panel discussion, Shearer described the move as “short-term thinking,” and expressed concern over Everton’s inability to secure a future clause for a player who could become a breakout star.
“It’s a decent addition on paper,” Shearer said. “But what’s the point if you can’t keep him? If he hits form, they’ve basically advertised him for someone else. That’s not smart planning.”
This sentiment has been echoed by fans, analysts, and former players. The Cordero deal is viewed by many as a potentially positive addition to a squad lacking depth up front — but one that does little to offer long-term value if he can’t be retained.
A Player of Promise
Antonio Cordero, who currently plays for a La Liga side (undisclosed for now), has been turning heads in Spain’s youth and reserve competitions. His technical skill, pace, and ability to find space in the box have made him one of the most exciting under-21 attackers in the Spanish game. Everton have reportedly tracked the youngster for several months and view him as a versatile attacking option.
The issue, however, lies in the structure of the agreement. According to reports, Cordero’s parent club have refused to include an option to buy, instead using the Premier League as a showcase for his development — potentially boosting his value ahead of a sale elsewhere.
Everton’s Bigger Problem
For a club like Everton, currently undergoing a difficult rebuild both on and off the pitch, moves like this reflect a deeper problem. Without financial stability or European football to attract marquee players, Everton have increasingly turned to temporary solutions to plug critical holes in their squad.
Alan Shearer’s frustration likely stems from a pattern of similar deals that fail to provide long-term return. In recent seasons, Everton have cycled through short-term strikers — from Neal Maupay to Moise Kean and others — without establishing a consistent attacking presence.
“Everton need players to build around, not to babysit someone else’s future star,” Shearer added. “That’s not how you rebuild a football club.”
What Happens Next?
Cordero’s move to Goodison Park is expected to be confirmed early next week. Whether he impresses or not, the lack of a purchase clause means Everton could be left empty-handed next summer — regardless of his contribution.
And for Alan Shearer, that’s the real setback.
Word count: ~505
Let me know if you want this styled as a news post, blog, or video script!
